Emerging Media Demystified. From Upshot Interactive.


Archive for August, 2009


Now how much would you pay? Investing in Facebook content.

funnelOne of the topics talked about ad nausea in online marketing circles is measuring social media ROI. Another topic of equal weight is building your Facebook Fan base. For obvious reasons, the more Fans, the more of an audience you have to talk (and let’s face it, by “talk” I mean “market”) to, and more people who will share those messages with others.

If you look at your Fan Base as a group of individuals who have opted-in to receive messaging from you, beginning to calculate ROI becomes easier. For example, if you bought a list of people who fit your target demographic, you might pay anywhere from $5 to $100 CPM depending on the quality of the list.  I’d peg Facebook Fans as premium simply because A) they’re willing to receive messaging from you once they are a Fan and B) because there’s a greater likelihood for that message to go viral.

One of the ways to build a Fan base, and keep them engaged is to invest in building a Facebook App to integrate into your Facebook Fan Pages.  In a recent Forester study, it was reported that 55% of tweens and 42% of adults want to see social applications from their favorite brands. Audiences are definitely there, and willing to interact with quality applications from brands they use, follow and admire.

Facebook application development runs the gamut. We’ve done apps for less than $10K, all the way towards $100K. Let’s assume you invest $5K to initially create your Fan Page (anyone can create a Fan Page free-of-charge, but we’re taking the leap you’re investing a little in an agency to design and configure something nice), and then later add a Facebook App at a cost of $20K, you can establish an ROI funnel to measure the impact the total investment ($25,000) adds to your bottom line over time. So an ROI plan and funnel may take the shape of:

  1. Correlate expansion in Fans to app usage/adoption
  2. Send messaging to Fans that includes links to specials, coupons, etc. via your Fan Pages Wall (which subsequently appears on Fans Newsfeeds)
  3. Measure click-throughs on links, and ultimately, conversions
  4. Calculate cost-per-conversion against total Facebook investment
  5. Calculate direct sales from Facebook

Based on this, let’s assume Brand X builds a Fan Base of 50,000 people, and sends out specials once a week. From this, 5% click-through and 20% convert.  Extrapolated over 12 weeks, (assuming 500 conversions per week), that becomes a cost per conversion of $4.17 if measured over a 3 month time span. With a Fan Base of 250,000 we get as low as 83 cents—not even considering repeat business.

However, this assumes that things remain static, and in social media, it’s anything but. Inevitably, you aren’t starting out with 50,000 fans, and over 12 weeks, the Fan Base may grow past 50,000. Also consider some of your messaging may reach people (through social sharing) that aren’t Fans. As more time passes, as long as your conversion percentages remain consistent, and your Fan Base grows, your conversions costs get exponentially lower.

This last part, really, is one of the primary reasons to invest in Facebook Apps and Facebook Fan Page content. Chances are pay-per-click campaigns on Google will only rise in conversion costs, not go lower. What other online marketing medium around today can you identify where your cost per conversion falls the longer you market? Email? Well, maybe, but let’s face it, email is tired and attrition is high. SEO? Yes, but you should be doing that anyway. Twitter? Sure—same principles apply, but users are only engaged through your messages, not content they can interact with.

While investment in Facebook Development is front-loaded, it pays off the longer you stay engaged and relevant to your fans. Additionally, some agencies (ourselves included) create arrangements where development can be paid over time, so that ROI can be realized more quickly, and in parallel to development fees. We predict once the Facebook Gold Rush settles, more agencies and marketing departments will adopt similar ROI calculation models, further justifying investment in the platform.

If you liked this post, share it:
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • Facebook
  • Google Bookmarks
  • Furl
  • LinkedIn
  • NewsVine
  • Reddit
  • Technorati
  • TwitThis
  • Live
  • MySpace
  • Tumblr
  • Yahoo! Buzz
  • email
  • Print

Visit our main site or check out our social & viral marketing services to learn more about Upshot Interactive. Also, feel free to drop us a line anytime.


Worst. Quiz. Ever.

sharkWho doesn’t like a good online quiz? Take a leftover from Web 1.0, add a dash of social networking, and it would seem quizzes are the hottest thing online.

Of course, we all complain we’re inundated with Facebook quizzes, but hell, we all take them now and again right? These quizzes help broadcast our personality, provide a sense of voyeurism into our Friend’s lives, and create a distraction from, well, the economy for one. They are also an easy way for brands to create content for Fans (see our last post).

Which brings me to (insert Simpson’s Comic Book Guy voice), the Worst. Quiz. Ever.

Last night kicked off Discovery Channel’s Shark Week 2009, and Emerge designer extraordinaire Josh Webb turned me on to the “What Type of Shark Are You?” quiz, found on the Discovery Website promoting, you guessed it, the ever-popular Shark Week. I hesitate to even share the URL, but to truly get a sense of a quiz so horrific I would rather take the What Mr. Belvidere Character Are You? Quiz (doesn’t really exist) you can check it out at:
http://dsc.discovery.com/sharks/what-kind-of-shark-are-you-quiz.html

Let’s break down this marvel of Web technology:

  1. The quiz looks like it was designed, and written, by a high school student.
  2. It asks TEN (yes, 10) completely nonsensical multiple-choice questions about your life, and to prolong the pain, actually provides a “witty” summary after you answer each one, making the time to take this “fun” quiz excruciatingly long.
  3. The questions are accompanied by some the worst stock photography ever. It looks like they bought a stock photography CD from 1996 and used every photo on it, along with attributing each photo in the quiz to Getty Images. (Did Getty pay for this mention? Were the photos so expensive Discovery had to get Getty to subsidize the project?)  C’mon you are THE DISCOVERY CHANNEL! How about some really freakin’ cool pictures of sharks or even what they eat? Better yet, how about a few badass videos of a Great White jumping out of the water in between answers? I realize the point is to show pictures that are associated with the questions, but really, do we need to see a picture of a “sensitive guy” when we’re asked about well, whether we’re sensitive? We get it.
  4. The results make zero sense and I’m pretty convinced it’s flawed. The quiz tries to take your answers and summarize them in the form of whatever shark you happen to be; however, the responses did not match the answers I gave. In fact, Josh, his wife, and myself were all Hammerhead Sharks. This leads me to believe all results are, you guessed it: Hammerhead Sharks.
  5. You can’t share the results. I can’t post my results to Facebook, invite my friends, or even email them. Yes, the page has the standard “Share” button on it, but this is likely simply because it’s part of Discovery Channel’s sitewide template.

OK, I realize I’m picking on Discovery Channel, but like every other red-blooded American, who doesn’t like Shark Week? For shame. Admittedly, I have no idea when this quiz was created. For all I know, this quiz was created in 1996, by an intern before social sharing existed, and the idea of using good content to help promote your brand—in this case, Shark Week, was commonsense. Maybe they are just repurposing old stuff.

However, the quiz is featured right on the Shark Week homepage, and, like I said, it is…um…Shark Week right now. Summary? Just another fine example of putting up content for the sake of content, and alienating your fans.

If you liked this post, share it:
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • Facebook
  • Google Bookmarks
  • Furl
  • LinkedIn
  • NewsVine
  • Reddit
  • Technorati
  • TwitThis
  • Live
  • MySpace
  • Tumblr
  • Yahoo! Buzz
  • email
  • Print

Visit our main site or check out our social & viral marketing services to learn more about Upshot Interactive. Also, feel free to drop us a line anytime.